@djjd62,
djjd62 wrote:
okie wrote:I still consider it as hard or tougher in some ways than going to Vietnam.
i can only hope you express this sentiment to the wrong (or right depending on the pint of view) vietnam vet, probably get you seriously fucked up
As maporsche, McGentrix, and possibly others I am not sure, have already pointed out how you are wrong, I will point out the obvious again, you are wrong, djjd62. Fact is, if you knew anything about the military, and especially about the Vietnam era and Fort Polk in particular, you would have enough sense not to say something like that. And by the way, I know quite a few Vietnam vets pretty well, and I have discussed these things with them, and most either agree or understand totally.
To try to explain it to you, and if you have never been in basic training, especially if you haven't been in basic training in the Vietnam era in Fort Polk, here are some basic things you should know. From the very minute you arrive at the base, the guys assigned to do the training made it their mission to make sure you received the training that would prepare you both physically and mentally to endure combat situations for prolonged periods of time as would be necessary for a year tour in Vietnam. Most of the guys trained in the units I was in there ended up in Vietnam, both basic and AIT. So, from the minute you arrived there, the schedule was filled with emotional and physical pressure, and harrassment was a big part of it from the time you get up in the morning until you went to sleep at night. Probably it would not pass now, but I personally witnessed a guy slugged as hard as the drill sargent could give it just outside the mess hall, I saw a guy break down and cry, I saw a guy fall out of formation while running to the rifle range due to exhaustion and the drill sargent come and physically kick the guy and told to get up, only to realize he was in serious trouble and the ambulance picked him up. I saw troops do the low crawl for their mail, sometimes for 25 yards at least or more. Plus the things I mention above, the standard was getting up at approximately around 4 almost every single day, intense physical training every day, lack of adequate sleep, and constant commands and directions, whether we were outside or inside to for classes. Besides that, our clothing had to be kept tip top shape and shined boots, polished brass, a bunk and foot locker according to form, and so forth every single day. Almost every single minute of every single day was scripted by the training staff, and personal time was almost non-existent, except for maybe short times on some Sundays.
If you have ever heard of a "blanket party" for drill sargents, you would understand. I heard about them, but never saw one, but I can understand why they might have occurred.
So if you had been there, you would also understand that in some ways it was worse than Vietnam. In Vietnam, although the danger was the primary consideration, the attitudes of officers toward non-coms were totally different and better, the dress code and constant commands and harassment pretty much totally disappeared and were replaced with an attitude of cooperation and "we are in this together" feeling. I won't say that in totality that basic training was worse than Vietnam, but in some respects it was in some ways, which is all I said. To tell me I don't know what I am talking about is only to reveal your own lack of knowledge. I have talked to other Vietnam vets as I am and I think most agree with me, depending upon where they trained and for what they trained, their MOS. I also am aware that a relative of mine was in the Marines in a much worse area of Vietnam and I don't think he would agree with me, although the training for Marines was as intense or moreso than the Army. Also, you should know also that my experience in Vietnam was in the infrantry as a "grunt," so you cannot claim my job was easy there, although my tour of duty came after the worst periods there that included for example the Tet Offensive.
If you knew what I knew, you would know why I jumped onto John Kerry so aggressively when he made the claims he made about Vietnam which clearly demonstrated his lack of honesty or knowledge about it. I joined the Swift Boaters for Truth and that is how I ever got started on any debate forum, when that forum sort of ran its course, I sought out another one and ended up here.