@farmerman,
farmerman wrote:
How is the GOP (ie Rushies) spinning the EMbryonic stenm cell issue? Are the partisan dearies gonna be a monolith when it comes to science and med?
fm, the best analysis of this, I heard by Lars Larsen, using guest experts on both sides. Here is my take, based upon that and what I have known about this previously.
Contrary to popular insinuated information, there has been alot of stem cell research prior to now, mostly with adult stem cell research, which government does support and has for many many years, again contrary to insinuated beliefs in the public. And private embryonic stem cell research is being done, although not publicly funded, again contrary to popular belief. And so far, many more treatments, a dozen or two at least, have come forth from adult stem cell research, in contrast with embryonic stem cell research, which has not so far resulted in anything very promising, again another point that has been ignored and mis-reported. Further, due to the biological nature of embryonic stem cells, they may offer greater problems and risks in regard to unwanted growth, etc. And although it seems that right now that embryonic stem cells used in research come from unwanted stem cells in laboratories that will be discarded anyway, the acceleration of embryonic stem cell research may very well use these up and thus stimulate the possible trafficking of stem cells, from who knows where? It opens up a slippery slope and highly questionable moral problems, over and above what currently surrounds the issue.
So my take on this is government money gives the false impression that finally stem cell research is now finally being started, thanks to Obama, which is a lie, and secondly that it somehow opens up the liklihood for some immediate treatment to make the crippled walk, which is another highly skewed expectation. And third, the most likelihood of a breakthrough probably still lies in adult stem cells, which has been going on a long time.
My conclusion is that there has been a mountain of disinformation on this issue, thanks to the mainstream media which has done a terrible job of researching this and reporting on it so that the public understands it, and the scientific prognosis and likely direction of progress for this is not anything like what it has been portrayed.
Embryonic stem cell research is celebrated by the abortion crowd, as a way to soothe their conscience, but the entire issue has been mis-represented and mis-reported, and generally not properly understood by the public.