georgeob1 wrote:Perhaps they are conscious of the self-fulfilling potential of their ritual action to 'exercise this power' - and, as well, of the destructive effects of the example of no action on their part.
However we did get a relatively soft landing from the deflation of a very large bubble in 1999. It may be that the effect of this (we hope) damping of the economic cycles may be to avoid the occasional wild excursion at the cost of amplifying some of the miler cycles.
Hi georgeob1,
You may be right but I have certain doubts. Why? When/if inflation runs rampant for a true and fundamental economic reason i.e. commodity prices, labor shortages (whatever it takes to have too many dollars chasing too few goods) I suggest we will again see a rather ineffectual Fed doing the only thing it can, raise the hell out of the short end until the economy chokes.
Also I have never seen any accurate long term studies showing any economist or central bank has ever been able to accurately predict inflationary trends. Without any real ability to predict interest trends by the Fed I suggest the Fed is just pissing in the wind (except in extreme cases such as a stock market crash or rampant inflation).
Consider: If it was really possible for a central bank or economist, they could easily earn as much money as would wish as the equity markets and even more so the bond market is predicated on interest rate trends.
Consider: Even if in the past for some period of time, it could be argued that a central bank or economist did predict interest rate trends, there are at least two factors working against continued predictions.
1) Return to mean (ask me to explain if you do not understand)
2) The efficient market theory (ask me to explain if you do not understand)
As far your belief that the "relatively soft landing from the deflation" was because of *predictive * Fed action I suggest the following scenario: Put 100 coin flippers in a room. They keep flipping their coins until only one coin flipper is left that has consistently gotten heads. I ask you georgeob1:
1) Is that man an expert coin flipper?
2) What are his chances of getting heads the next time he tosses?
Cheers,
Chum