Here's where the logic falls apart
Quote:(6) setting an artificial timetable for the withdrawal of United States Armed Forces from Iraq, or immediately terminating their deployment in Iraq and redeploying them elsewhere in the region, is fundamentally inconsistent with achieving victory in Iraq;
This statement is where is all falls apart. When the deadline for the Iraqi constitution was approaching and there was a stalemate, President Bush was insistent that the deadline, which everyone agreed was abitrary, be adhered to. As he correctly noted, and every teacher and strike negotiator will confirm, deadlines produce compromises and results. They give everyone a target to work towards. Setting a realistic timeline for the withdrawal of US troops produces two things: 1> It shows the world that we are really planning to leave, not just paying lip service to it. This also takes some wind out of the local insurgency since dying to drive the US out seems kind of silly when you can just wait 18 months. 2> It forces the Iraqi government to come up with hard plans to take charge.
If we had published a timeline the day the Iraqi army surrendered, there would be no way to lose. If we publish one today, the US public is molified, the European critisism is diminished and the Arab street resistance is thrown into confusion. It is a perfect plan. To win in Iraqi, a deadline is a necessity.