sumac wrote:I'm of two minds when it comes to teaching "manners" or "civility" in schools. We are such a complex, multi-everything, very mobil culture now.
We know that there are so much difference and variation in the attached meaning to behavior - even region to region a century and more ago.
On the other hand, we know that a lot is lacking, is not being taught, by example or instruction; and that this causes a deterioration of society and our comfort level and sure-footedness in it.
Somebody, somewhere, ought to be the designated player to pick up the slack, but since it recks of values, I'm not sure that our educational system is the best choice. I can foresee lawsuits over the use of tax-payer dollars, and challenges to constitutionality.
The need is clear - the venue is debatable.
Hello, sumac
I would dearly have loved to have responded to your earlier post - about your life circumstances - but honestly I felt I didn't know you well enough to comment. But your concerns are very familiar ones to me. I
do know what you're talking about. My very best wishes to you. And to us all, for that matter!
But about manners & civility. That's another thing!
I tend to see what's perceived as the lack of manners as something other than pure selfishness. It seems to me to be more about the loss of "communal feeling" or the loss of meaningful connection/empathy with others. Brought about by relentless advertising ("You deserve the very best!" "Pamper yourself!") & the media. There's this idea, being put about constantly, that if you're not coping/loved/succeeding that you're a loser & it's
all your own fault! (And it's your turn to be evicted from the Big Brother household as a result!)
And it follows that, if you don't want to be one of these hopeless losers or rejects, you'd better do what ever it takes to be successful/popular/in charge! The message is: be ruthless, look after No 1 & show no compassion for those experiencing problems & difficulties. If you don't make it it's you're own fault!
I think it's very sad (& very lonely, too) for young people, especially, to be growing up in a culture that defines a person's worth on such a shallow basis. (I mean, Paris Hilton a hero? A role model?
Oh please! ) Is there nothing for them but to compete, win, be those most successful at any cost?
Jeez, I sound like an old hippy!
But a little bit of peace, love & understanding would go a long way in teaching kids "manners & civility". It's simply considering others, the bigger picture, as well as your own gratification. That's all.