au1929 wrote:For example if someone were to put a price on the head of one the politicians on the other side of the fence. Take your pick.
It is undeniable that any large group contains a few people who are unworthy. If it actually is a tiny minority, any attempt to imply that it betrays a fundamental unworthiness of the group is invalid. It would be an invalid statistical inference in any case. I can only hope that I would not make a point I knew to be logically wrong to advance my agenda.
The complication here, though, is that this man may consider the Judge to be guilty of murdering an innocent person. It's a complex issue, but I would certainly not defend an attempt to do injury to the Judge. If I believed the Judge was morally guilty of murder, I would try to work within the system to make what he did impossible in the future.