@Frank Apisa,
We have two fundamental disagreements. First of all, I believe that it is illogical to believe things with little or no evidence that they’re true. You have stated that you believe this is fine:
Frank Apisa wrote:
Brandon9000 wrote: It is always illogical to believe or guess that something is true with no evidence to indicate that it is true.
No...it is not.
My contention is that when one believes in a given proposition with little or no evidence, one tends to be wrong a lot. The technique doesn’t work. If one wants to be right about things, one should refrain from drawing conclusions until one has some actual information pointing to a conclusion. If you think guessing without evidence is a reliable way to determine truth, more power to you. I think you’re wrong. A guess based on nothing or nearly nothing is not as good as a guess based on relevant evidence.
Our second fundamental disagreement is this. You have said several times in different ways:
Frank Apisa wrote:If a creator god exists...and we do not know if gods exist...everything we see is evidence that it exists.
And if a creator god doesn’t exist, then everything we see is not evidence of it. You could prove any arbitrary suggested cause for anything with this reasoning. If you propose that A was caused by B, and you are correct, then A is evidence of cause B. If you propose that A was caused by B and you are incorrect, then A is not evidence of B. Therefore, phenomenon A cannot be taken as evidence that B is its cause. If I am a police detective and I find that person A has been killed, I cannot claim that person B is guilty of the murder and use the mere fact of A’s death as evidence. Yes, if B is guilty, the death of A is evidence of it, but we do not know if B is guilty. This logic could also be used to show that person C is guilty. I can only assert, and good police do only assert, that person B is guilty based on evidence that cannot easily be interpreted another way, like B’s fingerprints on the murder weapon. Your suggested logic is invalid.