@hawkeye10,
hawkeye10 wrote:And impassioned and long plea from TOM DASCHLE to pull Ukraine fully into the Western orbit and away from Russia. Somehow in all those words Tom manages to completely ignore the two biggest problems with that idea.
1) That Ukraine is in almost every way broken down and decrepit, needing tens of billions of dollars of investment and complete rebuilding
I don't think he ignored that. Didn't he call for giving them that very aid?
hawkeye10 wrote:2) Pushing Russia away, antagonizing them is going to be very costly and dangerous,
What will be costly and dangerous is not confronting Russia until after they've invaded the EU. Once things get that far, things will escalate quite rapidly to a large nuclear war.
We might be able to block Russia from invading the EU by making a large military buildup in eastern Europe and having a new cold war, but that will be pretty expensive (far better than letting things progress to a nuclear war however).
Keeping Russia bottled up with endless fighting in Ukraine will be quite cheap in comparison to the other options.
In addition to economic and military aid to Ukraine, we should also extend economic and military aid to Moldova. If Putin ever manages to plow through Odessa and into Moldova, it would be big a help if the Moldovans were capable of putting up a decent defense.
hawkeye10 wrote:and we do that over that hell hole way way over there next to Russia? WHY?
One, because it is the right thing to do.
Two, because it is cheaper than having a huge military buildup and new cold war (and
much cheaper than having a nuclear war with Russia after they invade the EU).
hawkeye10 wrote:Daschle says that " they deserve" it which may or may not be true but guess what, the Ukrainians dont belong to us.
We are not the ones who are trying to possess the Ukrainians. Putin is the only one here who seeks to possess them.
hawkeye10 wrote:Where is our interest here?
For some of us, we just like doing the right thing.
For others, we find bottling Russia up in Ukraine for the next 30 years to be a far cheaper option than a massive military buildup and entire new cold war (and far, far, far cheaper than waiting until Putin invades the EU and then fighting a nuclear war with him).