joefromchicago wrote:[
When did you become the arbiter of what is genuinely "desirable?"
Whenever I choose, just as you do, although unlike you, I'm trying to establish an objective criteria for human activities, in this instance it happens to be WRT pornography.
If you happen to be a moral relativist, then presumably anything goes...I'm not, I think reason can establish certain boundaries and place limits within categories for acceptable behaviour, ie, sex is the category, and this is acceptable, but behaviours that have no real satisfactory explanation other than acts of self-degradation should be rejected as worthy of moral support and IMO should be banned* from normal commercial channels of sale.
*nothing can stop people performing whatever manner of debauchery they choose behind closed doors, but I think beasiality and other sickening behaviours should be banned from sale.
Furthermore we try and distinguish between pathological drives and meaningful/productive drives....and for the life of me I can't see how it's meaningful to perform A2M.
I hold the view that Eric Fromm holds, which is that we use reason to establish morality, and that whilst the outcome of our reasoning can be upgraded, a massive departure from reason based assessments "might" represent a pathological mentality, rather than an elightened individual.
Society should adjust to mans needs{defined by reason} rather than man adjust to the various themes/activities which individuals who comprise society engage in.
Quote: Whether that somebody is psychologicall disturbed is, I think, quite another matter.
So you don't have an opinion yet??....WOW, I'm shocked, as you seem to be rather bright judging by your commentary in many other threads, so I'm forced to conclude there must be another reason why you're on the fence.
No comprehendo...!!
Quote:Certainly, sex is a biological drive. But if biology alone decided whether a particular practice was aberrant, then all non-procreative sex would be aberrant. And, frankly, some of the best sex is non-procreative
Biology is rather important here, as we know that the colon contains waste products, and is to be expelled accordingly, it's not supposed to be tasted or eaten, that's why it stinks and looks fairly ordinary.