0

# The Moral Dilemma #1 [1 vs 5]

Sat 29 Jun, 2013 01:18 pm

A train tracks splits into two tracks, there are workers working on each track. On one of the tracks, five workers are working, whereas on the other, only one is. You are at the switch that can divert the train on one track or the other. There IS a train coming.

Suppose also that your voice screaming would not reach any of the worker to move. They are also wearing really good sound proof ear muffs and are facing away from the train. They would not see the train coming. And when the conductor sees the workers, it would already be too late to stop the train in time.

Is it morally acceptable to use the switch to divert the train to prevent 5 deaths at the cost of one?
• Topic Stats
• Top Replies
• Link to this Topic
Type: Discussion • Score: 0 • Views: 2,799 • Replies: 5
No top replies

contrex

1
Sat 29 Jun, 2013 02:15 pm
As I said before, you clearly know nothing about railways. Railway workers of all types, whether train crew or track maintenance workers, operate under clear safety rules. This just wouldn't happen. Those dumb clipart pictures make your posts look even more stupid.

mars90000000

1
Sat 29 Jun, 2013 02:18 pm
@contrex,
Then don't reply

Problem solved.
0 Replies

contrex

1
Sat 29 Jun, 2013 02:39 pm
@mars90000000,
mars90000000 wrote:
They are also wearing really good sound proof ear muffs and are facing away from the train.

They deserve Darwin awards. They should die.
0 Replies

contrex

1
Sat 29 Jun, 2013 02:54 pm
Unless the train is travelling at walking pace, in which case the driver can stop the train short of the workers, it would probably derail on the switch, potentially killing all the passengers. So I'd do nothing. Also if the track is being worked on, trains should not run as the track would potentially be unsafe.
0 Replies

joefromchicago

1
Sat 29 Jun, 2013 04:58 pm
This is just another version of the Trolley Problem.
0 Replies

### Related Topics

Best Euphemism for death and dying.... - Discussion by tsarstepan
Cause of death..... - Discussion by gungasnake
Hypothetical question... - Question by nononono
A Philosophy of Mortality and Suicide - Discussion by JLO1988
Knowledge of Death - Question by mikeymojo
Good Bits of Culture on Death - Question by The Pentacle Queen
Death and what happens next? - Question by MrSteMurph
How do you view death? - Discussion by hamilton
why fear death??? - Discussion by hamilton

1. Forums
2. » The Moral Dilemma #1 [1 vs 5]
Copyright © 2024 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.03 seconds on 03/04/2024 at 01:18:41