@ossobuco,
I didn't take what you wrote as arguing at all. In fact, I feel we're pretty much in sync. I cannot listen to anything in the last few years that he's done at all. His voice, never a pretty thing, is a gutteral croak that raises my hackles.
Much to the chagrin of some of my friends, Springsteen I've heard too much of...for a lifetime. He was played to death in the 70s and early 80s on FM in Boston and at a few of my friends house's. One friend goes on and on on FB about his concerts which they attend even if it's long distance. Holy crap!
Somehow, my faves S&G as well as Paul Simon have escaped my being tired of. However, Garfunkel alone I tire of quickly.
I think it's because now I play a greater variety than ever... I don't play my older music very regularly. I listen daily to a mix of some classical, jazz...acoustic folk..world music and new artists far more.