Reply
Tue 13 Nov, 2012 08:34 am
Context:
At this point, godless materialists might be cheering. If hu-
mans evolved strictly by mutation and natural selection, who
needs God to explain us? To this, I reply: I do. The comparison
of chimp and human sequences, interesting as it is, does not
tell us what it means to be human. In my view, DNA sequence
alone, even if accompanied by a vast trove of data on biological
function, will never explain certain special human attributes,
such as the knowledge of the Moral Law and the universal
search for God. Freeing God from the burden of special acts of
creation does not remove Him as the source of the things that
@oristarA,
Quote:Does " interesting as it is" mean "although it is interesting"?
I thiiiiiiink it's a little more emotively stronger than "although it is interesting". That seems to demote its stature slightly.
Maybe another example would help.
Sweet as she is seems to state slightly more that she
is sweet.
Then again, maybe not.
What do you think, McTag?
@JTT,
JTT wrote:
Quote:Does " interesting as it is" mean "although it is interesting"?
I thiiiiiiink it's a little more emotively stronger than "although it is interesting". That seems to demote its stature slightly.
Maybe another example would help.
Sweet as she is seems to state slightly more that she
is sweet.
Then again, maybe not.
What do you think, McTag?
I agree.
Word position matters.
First place rules; second follows.
@JTT,
Thank you for the invitation to comment further.
I think in the is particular instance (of the original question) the phrases "interesting as it is" and "although it is interesting" have exactly the same force. imho the inversion does not change anything. Nor indeed the change from "as" to "although".
This is not to say that one could not build other examples where a hint of another meaning (approbation, disapproval, sarcasm, etc) might be present.
@McTag,
Wow sorry, that needs a small edit.
Quote:I think in the is particular instance
should be, of course, "I think, in this particular instance...."