@realjohnboy,
Quote:Are you with me on the logic so far?
Not really. I don't see why you should have to nag. The onus is on the players.
Unless you enjoy nagging. The Thursday game might be excluded.
I still think farmerman's criticism is valid as I did at the time. As I did before he offered it. Giving an advantage to overdog pickers is unknown in the betting industry because there would be no betting industry otherwise.
Green Bay are --10 on Sunday. Which is about 6 gets 1. Your method gives GB pickers evens. Which is an unfair advantage over Tico. If GB win in OT Tico gets +10. Deservedly. In your game he loses 1 and GB pickers win 1. Undeservedly.
I am just interested in the comparison between our two final tables. The winner in my game is the best judge of football. That cannot be said for the winner in your game.
A great deal depends on the motives of the players. NFL players are expected to play to win and it is a bit incongruous if we use their efforts in a game not played to win. UnAmerican even. The "aw shucks, ain't I a gump" approach for losers is unAmerican surely? Anti-evolutionary as well. The stock market runs on spreads.
I keep telling people that I am more American than most Americans.