@MontereyJack,
MontereyJack wrote:I keep thinking about David's version of utopia, where everyone is armed,
RESTORING the
status quo ante, as of the early 1900s
MontereyJack wrote:and what happens in the theater under those circumstances. Let's call the original madman with the guns X, and the "good guys" who are armed A,B,C, etc. X comes in with his multiple guns, throws an apparent smoke grenade, and starts shooting. When the audience realizes it's not a special effect, A knowing he's a good guy, pulls his gun and fires somewhere in the general direction of X, whom he can't see very clearly if at all.
No; that 's an
ineffably stupid thing to do.
U don't discharge a gun without knowing where the target is.
MontereyJack wrote:Now I've seen calculations that trained soldiers in battle actually hit something
no more than 1 time in a hundred,
"Calculations" huh?
How many times did Lee H. Oswald hit his target (
MOVING target??)
Did anyone tell him about the "calculations" Jack ??
MontereyJack wrote:and all these guys are almost totally untrained, certainly untrained under combat conditions,
so A's shot more likely hits someone innocent.
There is no reason to discharge your gun,
if u don't know what your target is.
What u wrote makes no sense.
MontereyJack wrote:B, knowing he's a good guy, but having no knowledge of who else is, sees A's muzzle flash,
thinks he's a bad guy and aims at him, probably hitting someone else, if anyone.
There was a kid, looked maybe 12,
who said that the killer was 3 feet from him,
pointing the gun in his face; (but he was unarmed).
Your scenario is grossly inconsistent with known fact.
MontereyJack wrote:C, knowing he's a good guy, but assuming the other shooters are in league, pulls his gun and fires at A's or B's muzzle flash, or maybe at X in the smoke. In seconds there's a murderous crossfire among all the "good guys" firing at all the other "good guys" wwhom they assume are bad guys because they're shooting, and X, amidst people running and screaming, trying to get away and hit by all those other 99 shots that go nowhere near the shooters. The carnage is even worse.
During the history of this Republic, has this
EVER happened,
outside of your imagination??
MontereyJack wrote:The ONLY thing that works is taking the guns away.
There is
NO jurisdiction for that, because America is a
FREE COUNTRY.
U forgot that, Jack.
Additionally, if people were robbed of their guns
thay 'd just get more guns;
MAKE them, if it came to that.
Have u seen fabrication on the motorcycle show,
American Chopper,
or on
American Guns, or making them on
Sons of Guns. Guns r simple machines.
Guns were made by hand, before the birth of Christopher Columbus.
Its easier n faster to make them now, with electric tools
and extant engineering plans. No problem.
When the police rob people of their marijuana,
thay just get more of it. When the police robbed people
of their alcohol in the 1920s, thay just got
more of it.
Accordingly what u said does
NOT make sense.
David