@BillRM,
Bill,
This thread isn't about the Duke Lacrosse team. It is about Trayvon Martin who was a teenager who was shot.
The basic problem is simple. The story being told by the shooter George Zimmerman and the police wasn't logical. It was contradicted by the facts. The more the facts came up, the more they didn't add up. Of course facts need to be carefully tested with a careful investigation leading to a legal proceeding.
And that was the issue, the police and the prosecutors made up their mind before doing a full investigation and then dragged their feet leaving Trayvon's family and friends hanging.
Trayvon's parents, friends and community have the right to demand that his death be fully investigated. That is the police's job and they clearly didn't do it competently.
So now, as we have insisted, a full investigation will happen. In this full investigation all of the facts are being collected and weighed in a careful process that will be handled in a court. Zimmerman will be represented and both sides will have access to all of the evidence.And we have an independent prosecutor that is putting her reputation on the line claiming that there is enough evidence to try Zimmerman. Of course you are right there is a risk that the prosecutor is being corrupted by the public nature of this case (this is as big a risk as the fact that the original investigation was corrupted by racial bias). But that is why we have a legal process where each claim will be carefully tried in a court of law.
This is what should happen any time there is a case with two competing stories of what happened-- especially when the facts don't match up with the original police narrative.
It seems you are basically saying we should stick to the original story for the sole reason that it was the police saying it.
It also seems to me that the legal process with evidence and due process and both sides being fully represented is the best way to make sure that justice is done.
That is if you really want justice.