Mhatte-Rhaye wrote:I apologize Portal Star. I wrote a response to your post on Friday but my computer messed up while I was posting it. It was much to long to redo so I gave up and went to sleep. And now... I forget what I wrote. It was something to the extent of...
Even though areas of the brain have been tested how are we to know supernatural events did not take place? They could not have been observed. It is easy for me to say that it can be a very hard journey for someone to prove or disprove the supernatural. I opened this topic to not really debate as much as to listen to different... odd... occurances. I can't really reply to anything that anyone else wrote lately because my attention span (or whats left of it) has left me for the timebeing.
Now I will leave to run into walls.
I've always had a fondness for the restless and those with ADD. Y'all are so cute, so energetic. Must be hard to sit in desks all day.
I probably didn't state this a clearly as I could have, so let me try to elaborate on this point I made earlier:
You are right, if somthing is supernatural there is no way physical things or our senses could detect it (you'll find more on this in g-d arguments.)
However, these people are claiming that the supernatural is affecting our -physical- world. In the case of a candle tipping over, or metaethics extending the battery life of a cd player with his finger. Where the supernatural is said to influence the physical, there is a cause and effect.
ex: 1
Cause: supernatural ghost is pissed that people on television are in it's house.
Effect: ghost knocks over candle.
ex: 2
Cause: metaethics waving his finger with some supernatural battery-influencing power
Effect: cd continues to play on seemingly dead batteries.
So you see, the claim is that the cause is supernatural, but the reaction happens in the physical world. Therefore, if we can find the cause to be somthing physical, then it is not somthing supernatural (non-physical.)
for example, if we found out that instead of a ghost, there was a (cause) wire which was pulled and (effect) caused the candle to tip over. Or, we could test the cd player without Metaethics waving his finger, and if it still went back up on battery power we could attribute that to somthing in the mechanics of the cd player/batteries rather than the supernatural.
You see what I'm getting at? So as long as there is part of the cause - effect equation going on in the material world, it is subject to material properties - and observation and testing.
------------------
On another note, stories are fun, so feel absolutely free to continue the discussion on a non-philosophical level.