@Mujahedin,
Mujahedin;6825 wrote:Of course they would have a trial. I'm also sure it would be a lot fairer than the ones planned for the prisoners at Gitmo. Many who were swept up by the military, sent to Gitmo, , have no charges brought against them, have no access to a lawyer, or even know why the hell they are there. The fact that the confessions that were obtained, were done under duress (water boarding, etc.) won't help them either, because Fuhrer Bush said they have no rights.
Quote:Of course they would have a trial.
Why a trial when you as they already have them convicted? Fair, not in the least.
Quote:I'm also sure it would be a lot fairer than the ones planned for the prisoners at Gitmo.
Really, if it's up to you. They go automatically to the slammer? Fair, not in the least.
Quote:Many who were swept up by the military, sent to Gitmo, , have no charges brought against them, have no access to a lawyer, or even know why the hell they are there.
!. They know why they are there. 2. They are still alive. In stead of charges why don't we just behead them like they would do us? Fair, i think so. In war there need be no charges or lawyers or trials for enemy combatants. None of whom fall under Geneva conventions guidelines. And by Geneva convention guidelines they are not being tortured.
Quote:The fact that the confessions that were obtained, were done under duress (water boarding, etc.) won't help them either, because Fuhrer Bush said they have no rights.
What is your policy on extracting info from enemy combatants. How did you do so in Nam? How did your fellow soldier do it. How bout the VC. Did you play fair while you were there? Or was it lopsided? If a little duress would save a fellow soldier would you do it? Would you torture if it saved a thousand troops, or what about a million civilians? I think if you answer all honestly you might be labelled "Fuhrer Bush" or a hipocrite?
In any case they may have human rights but they sure as hell do not have Constitutional rights, that is reserved for citizens. Guess what, if you plot against this country even if you were born here you are not a citizen but a traitor. And will probably be hung, personally i like beheading them. Fair?