@kennethamy,
kennethamy;136436 wrote:I suppose that if Time is subjective, then unless there were people, there would be no Time and everyone would be in a terrible hurry since they wuld have had no time to do anything. So we would have to wait for people to come around before there was Time. But what would be happening in the meanwhile? And would people relax a little when that happened? Does Hegel have anything to say about this dialectical crisis?
It's important to distinguish between time and movement. And also to consider that Hegel abolishes/reduces the mind-matter distinction to what it is, a distinction imposed by the "it," as one can no longer just say mind.
It's a sublime idea, really, this "geist," but admittedly not practical. The point is difficult to grasp, but quite profound. Einstein seems to support it. Spacetime is a mathematical twist on Hegelian time.
I also note that we imagine time spatially, therefore continuously. The experience of sound re-enforces this. But entertain this thought experiment. How would humans experience time in the absence of concepts? including conceptualized memory and desire/fear?
Consider also that physics time is a useful human invention, so useful as to become to the dominant way we consider time..but not the
only way that it can be understood....
---------- Post added 03-05-2010 at 07:19 PM ----------
prothero;136603 wrote: If there is no process or no change there is no time. If there is any change, then there must be time.
I agree with your post, except for this point....
I think we need to step back, and consider the relationship twixt time and change. Is the perception of change
possible in the absence of memory? Imagine a human with a 0 second short term memory. What is time in this case? I argue again that time is imposed by the concept, and its emotional components (desire/fear).
---------- Post added 03-05-2010 at 07:20 PM ----------
Zetherin;136569 wrote:Yes, how we perceive time, and time, are different. How could someone confuse the two?
I see what you are saying. But this is why Hegel is profound. He thought hard on the issue. What is time except for our
concept of it?
Where is time? Could you explain time to a person with
no memory?