@kennethamy,
kennethamy;127540 wrote:Go ahead and imagine it. The sentence, "Mars is the fourth planet" does not mean "I had two eggs for breakfast" in English. It is strange that I have to tell you that. Of course, someone might intend that sentence to mean that, as in a code. But that doesn't show it means that, does it. Intending to mean something with a sentence is very different from meaning it. It isn't up to some particular person what words mean. Words mean what fluent people collectively mean by them. The fact that I may use a sentence to convey something in a code doesn't mean that the sentence means what I intend it to mean in a code.
If my friend and I collectively understand the meaning of a word to be a certain way, that is in fact what gives it meaning. That is the nature of what we refer to as "inside jokes." They will not be funny to everyone because they only have a collective meaning those who understand the underlying meaning of the joke.
Would you say that because I tell someone an inside joke, that it is intrinsically not funny because not everyone who understands English will not find humor in it?
I find most of my friends inside jokes quite funny, and I don't believe that makes me unreasonable. Therefore, the meaning conveyed by the joke is contextual and not intrinsic.
---------- Post added 02-12-2010 at 12:24 PM ----------
Fil. Albuquerque;127546 wrote:
Our friend Kenneth tends to be operating under the assumption of a tyranny existing over words.
Freedom for language!! :sarcastic: