@Sidus,
Sidus wrote:But what about the concequences to a society that believes that it is okay for a woman to "choose" whether or not her child should live or die?
And what about a society that has an unsafe abortion "black market" as ours once did? And what about the implication for womens' ability to participate in society when they are legally committed to carry an unwanted pregnancy? These are the other sides of the debate.
Quote:You obscure the debate by talking about fetuses who will be born extemely defective (a rare occurance).
No, just illustrating how absurd is the argument that a zygote deserves the same moral consideration as any other human -- which is exactly what is meant by the idea that it's murder to kill a fertilized egg.
Quote:I believe in capital punishment
A separate debate, but it's hard to justify capital punishment in a system that is blatantly racist and that's at such peril of executing someone who is innocent.
Quote:And don't fool yourself, the majority of abortions arise not because the fetus is a "zygote" but from an irresponsible wish to rid oneself of an outcome that was not desired.
It's hard to see this point as analytical when you see the need to infuse it with your own moral judgement. Furthermore, whatever the statistics, you're conflating within "irresponsible" pregnancies among rape victims, among minors who were too young to fully understand consequences, and among women carrying a baby with a major congenital defect.
And if you say it's ok for rape victims to have an abortion at 12 weeks gestation but NOT ok for an "irresponsible" teen at the same gestational age, then you're not attaching ANY moral significance to the baby -- you're only passing judgement on the mother.