I looked at some of the blog post and some of the comments. This exchange is at the top of the list:
Quote:Craig: No Citizen Kane?
Caitlin Kelly: Great film, too. It would be tough for me to move any of these from the list....
I can just picture Caitlin Kelly now, pondering her choices: "well, Citizen Kane certainly qualifies, and it's a great film, I'll admit. Still, I'd have to move something off of my list to fit it in. Let's see --
Citizen Kane or
The Paper? Hmmm.
Citizen Kane is widely regarded as one of the greatest films of all time. But
The Paper has Michael Keaton and it's all about a newspaper like the one I worked at, plus it's in color. And I've actually seen
The Paper. Man, this is really tough...."
I'm not saying that Citizen Kane is, without question, the greatest film ever, but if Caitlin Kelly is having trouble fitting it into a list that contains
The Paper and
Deadline USA, then I seriously have to question her qualifications to come up with a list of great journalism movies -- or
any list, for that matter. I don't think I'd trust her with a grocery list.