It comes down to this:
Every Gitmo prisoner who is released because of your support (and the support of like minded fellows) who takes up arms and kills an innocent (American or otherwise) is part of your karma --- hold it on your heads.
Whisper in my ear how this is acceptable based on principles of international justice.
This is logically flawed. By your argument, every criminal in jail right now who is released, and then commits another crime, is on your
head, Finn. Because you support a system which eventually releases people instead of confining them for life.
I think the little factoid that many of those in Gitmo never killed anyone and never had anything to do with AQ may also be a little damaging to your argument. I note that you carefully avoid mentioning this well-known problem with keeping people detained there.