@dyslexia,
dyslexia wrote:Interesting; I think if anyone took the time to print out the entire "interviews" of McCain/Obama with each question followed by each answer and compared them side by side one would find that McCain did not answer many questions or did them with anecdotes nonresponsive to the actual question while Obama actually attempted to give complete and comprehensive answers. The biggest failure of Obama's was his answering to the questions rather than to the audience while Mccain answered to "my friends" the audience. Obama must learn to play the audience as well as answer the questions.
Very interesting and perceptive comment, dys. However politics is all about people. A candidate more interested in the abstract elements of a question than the likely motives and interests of his questioner, is not likely to succeed over time in a democratic system. He may make a good pedagogue, or even a good writer or historian, but is not likely to meet the leadership demands of a democratic system.
I also think you are overstating the difference a bit: Obama did indeed play to the audience on several occasions, and McCain did forthrightly and directly answer most of the questions put to him.