China’s billionaires, twenty in number, unlike India’s, are on average younger, have less advanced educational degrees, were almost all educated in China and only 10% inherited wealth. Sixty-five percent are fifty years or younger. Their total wealth is $29.8 billion dollars.
While most Indian billionaires inherited wealth and then built their fortune by using economic power to secure neo-liberal policies, in China almost all billionaires inherited and secured political influence through kinship ties as the basis for building their economic empire. The Chinese billionaires early on converted political ties to secure lucrative public enterprises, land, export subsidies, loans, import and export licenses, which facilitated the rapid accumulation of wealth.
China and India the ‘emerging world powers’ have in fact created a powerful political machine for manufacturing newly minted billionaires, blending new elites with old money and family networks. The ‘new class’ is the engine of monstrous class inequalities and high growth enclaves in the midst of a sea of misery. The prosperity and opulent wealth of the new metropolises , full of high-rise offices, luxurious apartments, and palatial mansions belies the vast poverty and yawning gap between the super-rich and the hundreds of millions,abused,scorned and feared. Today in China, discontent is widespread and fragmented: If and when the alienated masses come together, it might make the first ‘Cultural Revolution’ seem like a polite garden party.
The concentration and wealth of the Indian billionaires ($191 billion dollars) far exceeds the wealth of their Chinese counterparts ($28.9 billion dollars). In fact the total wealth of the top two Indian billionaires is $52.1 billion dollars, almost double that of all 20 Chinese billionaires together. The world’s greatest inequalities are found in India where the wealth of 35 billionaire families exceeds that of 800 million poor peasants, landless rural workers and urban slum dwellers.
Contrary to conventional wisdom, the majority of Indian billionaires are not young, high tech, innovative, competitive billionaires. Over seventy percent are over fifty years old, one third do not have a university degree, less than one fifth have Masters degrees and fifty-seven percent inherited a substantial part of their fortune. The great majority of Indian billionaires started as millionaires — as part of the privileged upper class — and parlayed their long-standing family and political connections toward maximizing their profits. Over half (54%) of India’s billionaires accumulated their initial tens of millions through their monopoly positions in manufacturing, mining and construction and then took advantage of the liberalization, de-regulation and privatization policies of the Congress and BJP ruling parties to construct their billion-dollar empires.
While all of the billionaires are Indian citizens and claim primary residency in India, almost 90% of them have primary or secondary residency abroad in Australia, other Asian countries or the United Kingdom. While their initial wealth was derived from inheritance, manufacturing and services, almost one-third have reaped windfall profits from real estate speculation (shopping malls, special economic zones and residential housing) which has been fueled by high level and extensive corruption of top officials and the forcible removal of villagers and the urban slum dwellers.
While many Indian publicists and economists hail the ‘Indian miracle’ and classify India as an ‘emerging world power” because of the high growth rates of the past 5 years, what really has transpired is the conversion of India into a billionaire’s paradise. The in the price of land and real estate speculation has led to forced relocations of villagers to make way for new economic zones, where industrialists re-locate to avoid taxes, labor and social legislation while real estate speculators reap windfall profits. The growth of relative and absolute poverty, and declining living standards are masked by academics relying on absurdly low bench-marks of poverty — $2 dollars a day (World Bank Year Book, Washington 2006). In fact given the decline of public services and the de facto privatization of health and education, the rise in rents, regressive taxation, the re-conversion of land use, the lowering of trade and investment barriers — the very factors that have converted the privileged Indian millionaires in billionaires — 800 million Indian workers, peasants and the underemployed have seen a decline of their relative and absolute living standards .
http://www.dissidentvoice.org/2007/06/chinas-billonaires/