johnegq wrote:The town I live in is on a well water. My hardness was measured at 28! I am not joking. I currently have a Hague conditioner. It doesn't make a dent in water softening. This is a newly purchased home and all my neighbors are in a similar situation. Water this hard needs a big, industrial softener. The chlorine was measure as the same as a pool.
I agree that its the # of users and their usual gallons per day that is the main factor in size.
Who can compete with RainSoft? I beleive in the lifetime warranty thing. And no filter replacement is a large benefit too.
My record high hardness is 136, 28 is nothing special, a lot of places have higher hardness than 28 gpg.
Normally any softener can be used on up to 100 gpg hardness. So there is something wrong with your Hague.
"industrial softener".... not true. Industrial and commercial softeners remove hardness the same way as a "residential" softener, they are just huge physically where residential are smaller physically.
Or... you could say industrial/commercial contain more resin than a residential softener. Which requires a larger resin tank, which makes them larger physically.
They have much larger water lines to/from them. That's due to much higher peak demand flow rates than smaller ID water lines like in a house.... which is why the industrial/commercial softener is larger... to hold more resin AND their water is no harder than at the houses in their area.
So regenerated K of capacity is one part of correctly sizing a softener, and the peak demand flow rate is another part (actually the SFR of the volume of resin) and if you get that part wrong, the softener can not remove all the hardness no matter how hard the water is.
All the people in a 1 bathroom house will on average use the same 60 gals/person/day each BUT, in a 3 bathroom house, they'll be using water in more than one bathroom at the same time. A house with 3 bathrooms usually has a larger diameter (ID) water line than a 1 bathroom house.... That increases the peak demand gpm flow rate the softener must be capable of treating. Just like industrial/commercial softeners on say 2" water lines, it requires a physically larger softener and so the number of bathrooms does the same in a house. Even though the water is the same hardness, a larger motel needs a larger softener than a smaller motel on'n on..
Thereby the SFR gpm of the softener must be higher and the volume of resin controls the SFR of the softener and the volume of resin in the softener dictates the size of the resin tank; thereby the physical size of the softener. Does that make sense or not? To learn more about that:
Edit [Moderator]: Link removed
Any softener compares or competes with RS or any other softener. They all do the same thing, in the same way with little differences like dialing your phone number if it needs service (like anyone needs more phone calls or couldn't wait until they turn on their water!), soft water brine refill, variable reserve, variable brining, upflow brining or have a sensor in the resin bed that causes regeneration instead of metering.
Resin is resin, tanks are tanks, the control valve is the critical part, so buy the best control valve and you tend to get the best softener.
Cancel the contract for the RS and do more homework. There is no "lifetime" warranty that will protect you from paying anything for future failures of the softener. And remember, you pay a high price for that warranty when you purchase the softener.
What is wrong with paying less for the softener by hundreds to thousands of dollars and then fund the repair when you need it instead of prepaying it now?