@McTag,
I admit it was rather a fanciful comparison Mac but it made the point I think and it was intended to be memorable.
Edited highlights are not really about the sport being covered. They are more about sequences of dramatic moments which have minimal context.
Watching every ball of a five day Test match is an educational experience as well as being, for lovers of cricket, entertaining. With EH it is just entertainment. Or filler. The commentators, who are all vastly experienced professional cricketers and, in the main, ex-captains of their respective national teams, present a picture of the game, and of life itself, which is incomparably superior to anything a school can teach. It is a question of submersion in an albumen.
And, by extension, it has applications to all live sport and to the workings of the production team and to relationships between people.
I have seen edited highlights of the Tour de France and they are hopeless compared to watching the whole of it live. I find EH boring and the full coverage fascinating.
Over the last few weeks I've been reading a few pages a day of a biography of Sven Goren Eriksson. I'm about a third of the way through it and it is quite apparent that those who get their football from Match of the Day know next to nothing about the game. MotD is all about great goals, moments of stupidity and short attention spans. It's voyeurism really.
The biog probes the inner workings and I love its Wilson of the Wizard style.
As you get older Mac you will find yourself needing to spend more time on the sofa and becoming absorbed in these things, which are essentially works of art, is one way of enjoying that time.
As a result of entering rjb's American football "Pick-Um" game last season, which I won, I watched those games shown live on our TV. I learned a great deal about their game and about the American way of life which I could never have learned from seeing a series of exciting disconnected touchdowns and their commentators can't lay a glove on our cricket commentators who I consider to be national treasures. They export civilisation.