Quote:I totally disagree with your accessment of Sanity, though.
First of all, your example of a person with Down's syndrom in relation to sanity is poor.
A person with Down's syndrom is not necessarily insane, though they might be. But having Down's syndrom does not mean you are insane.
It means you have Down's syndrom, which you might want to do a bit of research on.
Ok, I will humor you. Here is what Wikipedia has to say about Down's syndrome:
Quote:Individuals with Down syndrome have lower than average cognitive ability, normally ranging from mild to moderate retardation. Some individuals may have overall average intelligence, but generally will present with some amount of developmental disability such as a tendency toward concrete thinking or naivete. There is also a small number of individuals with Down syndrome with severe to profound mental retardation. The incidence of Down syndrome is estimated at 1 per 800 to 1 per 1000 births.
I didn't say people with Down's syndrome were
insane (which carries a much stronger connotation than just being not sane). I mentioned that people with Down's syndrome could often be very happy, which carried with it the implication that I did not consider people with Down's syndrome to be sane.
Sanity is described in the dictionary as "soundness of mindd, judgement or reason." Therefore, people with Down's syndrome are generally not sane.
Quote:Secondly, not all people with Down's syndrom are happy. They are no different from the rest of us: some are happy, some are not, good days and bad days.
Well, you didn't say that saneness could contribute to happiness, you just said that "Rather, there are certain conditions that need to met so that a person is able to experience enough happiness" which implies that ONLY sane people can be happy. We only need 1 counterexample person with Down's syndrome to see that's not right...
Thinking about this more, I also don't feel that love is a necessary to be happy. I think that a lack of human connection can prevent happiness, but simple casual friendships without love I think can be sufficient, at least for myself.
Quote:I've seen absolutely miserable people, from all levels of ability and/or disability. At least in my experience, that has nothing to do with it.
So, then, you don't think sanity is a requirement for happiness? This seems to contradict what you said earlier. Or maybe you are making a distinction between temporary and long-lasting happiness.
Personally I don't think there is ANYTHING that can cause long-lasting happiness. I think that we need constant happiness-stimulation to remain happy for long periods, so if something were to provide long lasting happiness it would have to keep on acting rather than being an "impulse" force.
Quote:
It's hard to be happy when you are out of your mind, or going through a strong manic/paranoid cycle. I've never seen anyone do it. I've seen wicked humor, plodding along until it passes, enduring. Not what one would call 'happiness'.
Just my observations.
Yeah, ok, so maybe we should just say "insanity is a source for unhappiness" rather than saying that "sanity is a requirement for happiness"