cicerone imposter wrote: Thomas' opinion about having "baggage" from their ancestors might be one answer, but I think it's much more. What that is surely includes their parent's and peer attitudes.
Does Thomas Sowell explain this?
I haven't read
Black Rednecks and White Liberals. The quality of Sowell's work varies widely between serious scholarly work and right-wing think tank sludge. Since he chose to publich his
Black Rednecks with
a publisher specialized in the latter, reading it ranks fairly low on my priority list. But in
Ethnic America, which published with the reputable, scholarly, left-leaning
Basic Books, his thesis consists of two parts: 1) culture tends to get transmitted from parents to children, and from peers to peers. 2) In multi-cultural societies, such as Russia, pre-1918 Austria-Hungary, and most countries in the Americas, ones peers likely are the ones who share ones cultural background, or live closely to one, or both. By putting 1) and 2) together, he gets a mechanism of how culture gets transmitted down the generation.
I am speculating, not having read
Black Rednecks, that Sowell treats the stereotypical, violence-mongering, macho attitude among hip-hoppers and black gangs as an odd special case of this. A special case where a mindset was transmitted from violence-mongering, Southern, proletarian Whites to the Black population they were oppressing. That aspect of redneck culture then whithered away among the Whites who originated it, but survives in parts of the inner-city Black culture. At least that's how I understand Sowell's thesis, not having read his book, going by third party summaries and his own Op-Ed talking points. (In other words: please take my summary with several spoons of salt.)
So, to answer your question ci, his view of cultural transmission seems quite compatible to yours.