flushd wrote:Eorl,
Given my hypothetical case, the person should still have to be convicted for murder/manslaughter whatever.
The person killed.
The one who slipped the pills didn't.
It makes sense to take the state of the person into consideration, but it does not automatically delete a person's responsibility for themself.
Think of the implications if it did. Or rather, just look around.
"It wasn't my fault I did it, he/she/it did something to me !"
The implications of the opposite seem far worse to me.
"So the clinically depressed person killed themselves, sure I gave him a depressant, but I didn't push him...he jumped"
"So I gave her a gun, gave her extreme psychotic drugs (against her will) that induce paranoia and drove her to the school. I didn't shoot anybody though...she did. Her choice"
Nup, I'm not buying it.