Reply
Wed 2 Apr, 2003 02:00 am
Al-Jazeera show us the victims of this and other wars (including, crucially, President Saddam's war on the Iraqi people).
Congolese people are teetering close to starvation.
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (Sars) has caused more than 60 deaths worldwide, with more than 1,800 reported infections.
We see this daily in the news and papers.
And a great number of us doesn't want to see it.
We have sealed ourselves away from death in a way that is unique in all of recorded human history writes Johann Hari in a column in today's The Guardian.
What are your thoughts about this?
Deaths have been from ancient times, the question is in what attitude one dies.
A good number of Americans seem capable of ignoring death until it arrives personally for a friend or family member.
I've noticed that adults who read widely as children are more capable of handling misfortune than those who grew up in the Culture of Now.
Good topic, Walter.
Death's pain is relative to vicinity (physical, emotional or cultural). Everywhere.
If one was to put into a line, from the center of Baghdad, the coffins of Iraqi civilians killed by the recent bombings, it wouldn't reach the suburbs.
If one was to put into a line, from the center of Baghdad, the small coffins of children who died avoidable deaths during last year in Iraq (or Bangladesh, or Nigeria, or Peru), it would go past Nasiriyah (in some cases, it would easily surpass the Kuwaiti border). Every death a personal and family tragedy.
[This does not justify the war deaths, but is one of the reasons I find the "war kills children" argument so weak]
I've always been rather accepting of death. I've often identified with the saying from the moment your born you've begun to die. I'm not a dark or morbid person. I just tend to accept death as part of life. I've often noticed that people that don't tend to deal well with the topic often don't deal well with change in general. Hmm. . . . I think "Americans seem capable of ignoring death" because they tend to believe they can make things permanent for example the christian idea in our culture says that marriage should be permanent. We also don't tend to see death in person often. We don't tend to die young or from terrible diseases so what death we do see in the media we tend to approach with the same feelings one has toward death in movies. I'm a scientists so I guess I study I'm surrounded more with the reality and necessity of death more often than most Americans.
The dead children in Iraq possibly would not appreciate being written off as insignificant.
Their significance is emotional. Because we saw pictures of some of them. Because we now pay attention to them.
In terms of a person's own, unchangeable life, they're not more significant than the children who are dying of malnutrition, diarreah or AIDS in Pakistan, Nicaragua or Zambia.
Nature has a mysterious way of reducing the world population to some manageable level of the human species. c.i.