@Irishk,
Irishk wrote:
realjohnboy wrote:Disclosure: I have a dog in this fight.
Is that dog's name 'Brick & Mortar'?
I haven't seen any statistics on how much internet sales have hurt local retail businesses.
The article re Illinois vs Amazon estimated that states in total don't collect $20BN a year in sales tax from untaxed sales made over the internet (not just via Amazon). I can't verify that number.
Yes, I am a brick & mortar store competing with on-line sales. I realize that, unless we can redefine how we do business, we will probably disappear by the end of the decade after almost 50 years. So it goes.* No problem for me, as it turns out that my flagship store in Cville sits on a prime piece of real estate that will sell for an obscene amount of money.
But, this thing about sales tax grates with me:
> States and municipalities are desperate for revenue and this potential source of revenue is blocked (see more about that below);
> I start out at a 5% price disadvantage because of the sales tax. Is that a factor in how people shop? My employees say no; core price, convenience, and quick and free shipping on gizmos they buy online. But at least a couple of times a month we get requests for a quote on a relatively large sale. We work up a price and the customer will say, with a wink, "Can you ring it in as non-taxable?" I am proud that my employees-even the purple haired goths-
respond with a variation on "I don't get paid to break the law."
> Virginia has a Sales and Use Tax. Individuals are supposed to report internet purchase sales and pay the 5% on their tax return. The compliance rate is probably close to zero.
> I think that, but I am not sure, that when you itemize your deductions on your federal return, there is a table you can use to estimate sales taxes. Sales taxes you didn't pay. I may be wrong about that. Is that true?
Thanks for responding about this, Irishk. I realize we have moved on to other issues so this may be irrelevant, but I know you to be interested in stuff like this. I think that the issue will not go through Congress, but rather through the courts, again, regarding "nexus."
*Rant: People want me to hire their kid for the summer or contribute to silent auctions for some cause but when I ask them if they shop in my stores, they respond "Oh, no. I buy stuff online but I am sure other people do shop here."
Sorry for my long response to Irishk.