@BigTexN,
BigTexN wrote:
Quote:Therefore, the propping up of the bank and your loan, and all loans like yours, isn't it the same as paying for the inflated value of your house, and others like it?
The answer to your question is an obvious "No".
The loan value, once the loan is made, is unaffected by the inflated (or deflated) value of the home. The reason is twofold:
1) The amount of the loan is due regardless of the value of your house.
For example: On the downside - If my house is worth half as much, does that mean I owe twice as much as what I applied for? Or on the upside, if my house doubles in value, does that mean I now owe half as much as what I applied for?
2) The vast majority of mortgages are and were made to people who do not intend to sell simply because the market value went down. They bought their home to be a home. So, if I bought my $100,000 home for $200,000 with a mortgage worth $200,000, I will continue to pay my mortgage today just as I have been since the day I took out my mortgage to begin with. A person wouldn't simply 'walk away" because their house is worth less. They bought it to live in for more than a month and a half.
Banks, however, with mark-to-market accounting and regulated reserve requirements face a different scenario.
If they do a mortgage today for $200,000, transparency accounting will force them to list the actual value of that asset as $120,000 on their books. This is because there is no market for mortgages. So, if they tried to sell that mortgage in the open market, it would be worth 40% less than what they wrote it for. Therefore, they must show (mark) the asset on their books at the current market value.
That now becomes a "writedown of assets" and will require a "cash infusion" (government bailout funds) to bring their capital up to meet minimum reserve requirements.
Hence, no bank has any incentive to make any kind of loan....which leads to what the banks are doing now, hoarding the cash they get from Uncle Sam.
The quandry is that, without access to credit, the economy loses liquidity and stalls. But, if the banks make the loans and then they have the market-to-market accounting force them (on paper anyway) into insolvency.
Okay, perhaps for your house, you are paying the loan, but I am talking about the past practices of highly leveraging loans, as your house apparently is an example, if you look at the total pool of loans in this country that were highly leveraged to the hilt due to the practices that your home loan was a part of, we are paying for those faulty loan practices. Although you are paying your loan payments, there are enough other people that are not. Apparently a very high percentage of home owners do not live in those homes, and contrary to your desire to pay for your residence, other owners and especially investors that do not live in them do not care to pay for a house that is worth far less than the loan is worth, so they are walking away. The vicious cycle then comes into play, as more owners walk away, home values fall further, then more owners walk away, and so on, until the process stabilizes again at some point at a much lower home price market.
Again, those of us that did not leverage our house to the hilt are paying taxes to shore up banks and home owners that did. Specifically, we are paying for those people that walked away from loans, but the whole culture of highly leveraging homes and properties is at fault. That includes us, the public, that bought into the wisdom of buying homes in that manner.
Because I have always lived conservatively, I have always bought a home of less value than the real estate salesman told me that I could, and I always had a pretty good down payment to avoid having my home mortgaged for near its market value. My home now is almost paid off, and only due to some improvements and a line of credit, I now owe some, but less than 10% of its probably value. And similar to ci, the line of credit started out at about 4.875, but I am now only paying a little over 3%, so I don't have much incentive to pay more than the minimum each month.