Quote:I notice Bernie that you have edited out the part about what media had to gain from discouraging smoking. It was a share in a rather large pot of loot and it must have added to carbon emissions.
It is irrelevant. Get thee to a logic course.
Quote:Isn't every talking head telling lies more or less the whole time?
This is so undiscerning as to be worse than useless.
Quote:I didn't say that I don't accept tectonic science. I asked what proof is there that the artcic plate was once in equatorial regions.
Comparison of minerals, as the simplest example. Mineral deposits are distinct and unique and this allows mapping of zones of separation. For example, the eastward tip of Brazil and Cameroon. And in those two locations, not only will you find the same unique deposits but also the same spores (which last damn near forever) and other biological remains, and you'll find that the molecules of iron (which align to the poles while the rock solidifies) will be the same (the magnetic poles move over time, thus allowing this sort of mapping).
Quote:
Your positing of plate movement and climate specifics of a location on that plate at some period of time as some sort of bona fide teleological proof is just silly.
Quote:Well-assertions are silly and that's one. Positing is quite respectable I think. One is supposed to discuss what is posited and not just declare it silly.
Quote:
What might you not likewise claim constitutes a teleological proof, for goodness sakes.
fresco will set you straight on that. He's a Wittgenstein expert.
And I don't piss all over the bathroom floor either. You're projecting again. At the nozzle of the male urine disposal unit there is a mechanism of incalcuable complexity which imparts a twist to the jet of urine and thus enables men to direct it accurately. Females, alas, are not provided with such a system and there must be an explanation for this difference.
What would you posit Bernie?
sorry spendi but it is silly. Nothing would fall outside of your teleological argument. If it is, then it is designed, ipso facto. It is entirely circular and entirely useless.
Posit to answer what question?