I saw the episode with the rude NY millionares and the rustic woodchopping wife who drove a bus and the episode with the clean woman who made lists and liked quiet and the dirty woman who let her animals crap in her house on the floor and wanted to be her kids best friends. It seemed to me that they picked extremes and made examples, had an agenda they were pushing. Most people aren't as extreme as the people selected, and they haven't explained why they want to participate on this type of show.
It just doesn't have the playful edge TS has with its money twist.
Trading Spouses is better b/c it has the same feeling of stranger adapting to strange territory, but has the added twist of being about getting $50,000.00. You kind of understood why families wanted the money, even if you couldn't sympathize with their lifestyle choices. While it still seems edited to push force its premise(s) about families, it comes across as funnier with the twist about the money.
We've pretty much stopped watching either of them now that fall is here, we have school and other obligations and can't/don't sit around watching quite so much tv.
TS was entertaining w/its novelty over the summer, and while I understand that WS came up with the idea first, TS was on first, and set the standard, made us desire some irony that is lacking from what I've seen on WS.