Do opinions and ideas persist after death?

Forums: God, Life, Death, Logic, Puzzle
Email this Topic • Print this Page

When we die, assuming the self persists is it plausible that reality continues as ideas and opinions? Is God subject to perception, or to beliefs?

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Question • Score: 4 • Views: 7,590 • Replies: 33

[+3] - roger - 07/28/2016Well, I think that sounds quite brutal.

@Thomas33,

Let's assume Y=X^2.
A two dimensional curve consists of X and Y.
The projection of Y=X^2 on X axis is a simple straight line. (Y=0)
I think now we live in X axis( Y=0 or this world).
When we die we will see and touch newer axises. (X and Y or Life after death).
We will just see the more complete world.
What we saw once as a simple straight line would turn out to be a curve with it's extremums.
We will just see the reality behind the clouds of distances and spaces and time.
So nothing will be destroyed or disappeared.

1 Reply

@sky123,

All life will apply to whatever is post-death. Post-death will be blind to life.
However, if life is defined by subjectivity, is it possible for post-death to not in any way be another clash of meaning?
Life can be perceived as a clash of meaning, and so by default whatever's post-life must be free of that state; but how can that freedom possibly be no error, when the clash amidst life encompasses all meaning (including anti-meaning)?

0 Replies

@Thomas33,

Thomas33 wrote:

assuming the self persists

way too big an assumption to make

1 Reply

@ehBeth,

If the self perishes with death, can ideas if not opinions still exist?

2 Replies

@Thomas33,

Of coarse. Look at all the books written by dead authors.

1 Reply

@cicerone imposter,

I think that ideas cease.

0 Replies

@Thomas33,

They persist Tom in one's soul. That's everything about one except his body

Yes, no, it's pretty apparent one's consciousness goes poof. But everything else you leave behind is your soul

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

Quote:

But everything else you leave behind is your soul

I think rather than 'soul,' it's the impression they leave of who they were. Impressions are subjective.

1 Reply

@Thomas33,

Not quite sure though Tom, what means the self persisting

As far as reality I'd suppose you can perceive its continuance by defining the word as need be. So you might clarify a bit

But thank you for forcing an old guy to think a little. Getting harder and harder
No puns intended

1 Reply

@cicerone imposter,

Quote:

it's the impression they leave

Okay Cis but now you'll be asked to define "impression"

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

Quote:

im·pres·sion
imˈpreSHən/Submit
noun
1.
an idea, feeling, or opinion about something or someone, especially one formed without conscious thought or on the basis of little evidence.
"his first impressions of Manchester were very positive"
synonyms: feeling, feeling in one's bones, sense, fancy, (sneaking) suspicion, inkling, premonition, intuition, presentiment, hunch; More
an effect produced on someone.
"her courtesy and quick wit had made a good impression"
synonyms: impact, effect, influence
"school made a profound impression on me"
a difference made by the action or presence of someone or something.
"the floor was too dirty for the mop to make much impression"
2.
an imitation of a person or thing, especially one done to entertain.
"he did an impression of Frank Sinatra"
synonyms: impersonation, imitation; More

ergo: subjective.

0 Replies

@Thomas33,

Thomas, what is your first language?

1 Reply

@dalehileman,

The self would mean self-awareness.
The state of post-life obviously can only be speculated on, but I think a logical conclusion would be that whatever it is, it doesn't recognise our current perception of reality (ala ideas and opinions).

Does this rule out ideas and opinions? Of course not. I am however intrigued by the notion that ideas and opinions never existed to begin with, and therefore post-life won't be the absence of anything, just the true understanding.

Which I suppose is the real question: if understanding needs contrast, how can the state of post-life be justified?

0 Replies

@ehBeth,

I'll rephrase: if self-awareness perishes with death, ruling out opinions, is it possible that ideas continue?

Do opinions and ideas persist after death?

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know