I'm not getting your point. I've never denied the hypothetical possibility of a god; I'm just asking those who claim that there is one to support that claim with evidence. I've considered the possibility of the voodoo gods, magic, Shiva, etc etc, but I didn't jump on their bandwagons just because it made me feel good.
Like with your putative god, presumably the same one I used to believe in, upon investigation I simply didn't find any credible evidence to support the claim. Still haven't. Every argument in favor of it has been riddled with logical fallacies, including yours. But my mind is still open to the hypothetical possibility that someday someone might provide such evidence. I'm just not jumping on the bandwagon until someone does so.
For myself (and I think everyone MUST gather their own evidence) one piece of evidence was the unexpected correlation between the conclusions I reached when contemplating God's existence and the clues i found in the bible much later.
Not conclusive, I know, because you could say that I'm reading into it what I want or expect. I'm sure we've both seen examples of that.
The 'third leg' of the 'proof' for me was the unique nature of the story that emerged from my search. It was unexpected, unique and at the same time, appealing. And far beyond the basic Christian message of 'Jesus died to save us from sin, etc, etc.'. It was a good enough story to make me actually love this 'imaginary friend'.
For a time, I was tempted to doubt the 'story' myself because it would not make sense that I was the only one on earth who saw it. There are not many, but eventually I saw that there were others who had followed the same thread. Haven't met any in person but they do exist. They too have to express their story carefully to avoid being misunderstood, offending everyone around them or being thought mad, but knowing the story myself, I can recognize them.
I'm not sure what you mean by 'jumping on the band wagon' but as I've said before, you are the only one who is needed to start down the road. You don't have to join any parade. If it's a parade, it's most likely the wrong road anyway.