AA question

Forums: Alcoholism, Aa, A A
Email this Topic • Print this Page

Friend is going to an AA meetings for 17 years.
I didn't know. Just found out. What does it mean?

When do people actually decided to do AA? Or it is prescribed?
3 times per week...seems a lot to me. Is he in trouble?

Topic Stats
Top Replies
Link to this Topic

Type: Discussion • Score: 4 • Views: 2,841 • Replies: 36

[+3] - Wilso - 12/01/201417 years? He/she obviously gets something from the meetings that he/she needs. Remember that the second 'A' means Anonymous.
[+3] - BillRM - 12/01/2014[quote]If you want to know the success rate, google it. I'm not here to spoon feed statistics to you. If something I said piques your interest, none of what I've said is a state secret, and can...
[+3] - BillRM - 12/02/2014[quote]I don't believe you have any real interest in obtaining information in any form[/quote] That is your right to have your silly opinion as my wife tell me from time to time.

Could be court ordered, or a suggestion from a counselor or requirement for treatment.

0 Replies

@Eliusa,

Have you asked your friend why he goes?

There are a number of different reasons people go, but they are generally based in difficulty controlling substance/alcohol use without the support of others/God.

0 Replies

@Eliusa,

Quote:

When do people actually decided to do AA? Or it is prescribed?
3 times per week...seems a lot to me. Is he in trouble?

No court order is likely to run for 17 years.

0 Replies

He probably goes because it's really easy to pick up emotionally vulnerable women and having sex with them. He's doing it because his wife isn't safisfying him at home.

Rolling Eyes

1 Reply

@Eliusa,

It means there's probably a lot you don't know about your boyfriend. He probably told his wife he was going to a meeting when he was out on a date with you.

1 Reply

@Germlat,

LOL I KNEW someone will say that but no, it is a different person.
I am just surprised that I didn't picked it for all this time we had known each other. But I felt ashamed to ask because I always thought it is for freaks.
But he is like...normal. I could not even imagine him being drunk and crazy.

I am just wondering if they have to do something bad to get it ordered.
Seems like he said he is going willingly because it is good for him.
But WHY would anyone just go and waste so much time if it is not nesesary?
Is it fun?

1 Reply

No - trust him that it makes him feel good. It can be very therapeutic, but it's not therapy.

At some time, he decided that his life was getting out of control due to alcohol use. That can be financially, emotionally, health-wise, job-wise, relationship-wise. So talking with others who try to live one day at a time without drinking helps him feel better.

No, it's not just for "freaks" and you need to do some research on self help groups before you pass judgement on a person who attends one.

1 Reply

@PUNKEY,

Thanks for the info.
Sorry, I wasn't researching unless I cared, right? The reason I thought its for freaks was because I am passing by one of this facilities weekly and I see all these unfits standing there smoking and looking awful. I was always thinking it seems like they all hanged over from yesterday and what is the point going to such meetings?
NOW I have a different perspective, I actually KNOW a normal person who goes there and I am just surprised. I wanted to tell him like...are you hanging out with these hobos? But then I was just 'shut up'...lol
and I am glad I did.

0 Replies

@chai2,

So now anything I am saying is going to be about him?
I don't think so.

1 Reply

@Eliusa,

Eliusa wrote:

LOL I KNEW someone will say that but no, it is a different person.
I am just surprised that I didn't picked it for all this time we had known each other. But I felt ashamed to ask because I always thought it is for freaks.
But he is like...normal. I could not even imagine him being drunk and crazy.

I am just wondering if they have to do something bad to get it ordered.
Seems like he said he is going willingly because it is good for him.
But WHY would anyone just go and waste so much time if it is not nesesary?
Is it fun?

Here....click on this nice link below and you will learn everything you need to know. Then, you will not have to ask any more questions about it here, because it even provides a phone number for you to call and ask anything else.
It will provide much more information than anyone here can.

http://www.aa.org/

2 Replies

17 years? He/she obviously gets something from the meetings that he/she needs. Remember that the second 'A' means Anonymous.

0 Replies

@Eliusa,

Eliusa wrote:

So now anything I am saying is going to be about him?
I don't think so.

I didn't say anything about this being about anyone in particular.

AA is an excellent place for sexual predators to find victims.

It's also a place to meet some fine friends.

It does however, fill most if not all attributes of a cult.

Of course though, my saying that will cause someone to rush forward to say that AA says lives, helps people, etc. That it has. Even though that success rate is abyssmal. It's still a cult.

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-cult_a0.html

1 Reply

@chai2,

Quote:

It does however, fill most if not all attributes of a cult.

Of course though, my saying that will cause someone to rush forward to say that AA says lives, helps people, etc. That it has. Even though that success rate is abyssmal. It's still a cult.

Well I do not know a lot about them other then what everyone happen to know but the label of cult seems kind of strong. For one thing I never hear that they try to get a person family out of the equation unless the family members also have drug or alcohol problems.

Now as far as their success rate being low my question is low compare to what other mode of treatments?

My impression is that severe drug and or alcohol problems treatment of any kind have very low success rates.

1 Reply

@BillRM,

That's true Bill. You don't know a lot about them.

You probably don't hear a lot about what goes on there.

2 Replies

@chai2,

Quote:

That's true Bill. You don't know a lot about them.

You probably don't hear a lot about what goes on there.

OK full us in please, as I am fairly sure that I am not the only one that is not fully inform concerning the AA.

By the way you stated that their success rate is low so my question is what programs/treatments have a better result then the AA.

footnote as a card carrying atheist I would have a problem with the religious elements in their program.

1 Reply

@BillRM,

Well, since you didn't click on the last link I provided (the 2nd of 2) which would have answered any and all questions as to it's cult atmosphere, I'll provide a similar one below that goes directly to the questions. It lists 100 attributes of a cult, and you can switch back and forth for the answers.

From the scan I did of maybe half of them I'd say it's pretty spot on. It ranks each of the attributes on a scale of 0 - 10. Some are obviously a zero, like "mass suicide" but there are a lot of 8, 9, and 10's in fact, on a quick glance, I saw some rated lets say a 7, that I personally would have said a 10, and vice versa. Mileage may vary.

Anything I could relate is written right there for you to read.

If you want to know the success rate, google it. I'm not here to spoon feed statistics to you. If something I said piques your interest, none of what I've said is a state secret, and can easily be found.

Here's that link...have fun.

http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-cult_q0.html#cq_guru_right

1 Reply

In fact Bill, here is a thread from long ago, where I was more inclined to exercising my fingers on the keyboard.....

http://able2know.org/topic/145152-1

1 Reply

@chai2,

Quote:

If you want to know the success rate, google it. I'm not here to spoon feed statistics to you. If something I said piques your interest, none of what I've said is a state secret, and can easily be found.

Perhaps but it was you who stated that their success rate was tiny so asking you to back that statement up does not seems unreasonable to me.

1 Reply

@chai2,

chai2 wrote:

That's true Bill. You don't know a lot about them.

You probably don't hear a lot about what goes on there.

I've been to AA and NA meetings. What goes on People share their experiences of inebriety and sobriety. Have a cup of tea or coffee and chat. Go home. I've never seen anything else.

2 Replies

AA question

Related Topics

Quick Links

My Account

able2know