Sterling trial set for Monday, Donald's competency no issue
David Leon Moore, USA TODAY Sports
June 30, 2014
LOS ANGELES – Next week's Sterling vs. Sterling probate trial, with the proposed $2 billion sale of the Los Angeles Clippers hanging in the balance, will not be about whether 80-year-old Donald Sterling can spell "world" backwards or draw a clock.
The lawyers representing Donald and Shelly Sterling, asked Monday by Judge Michael Levanas to work out a trial outline, returned to court and said they had stipulated that Donald Sterling's mental capacity was no longer an issue.
Levanas denied Donald's lawyer's request for a continuance, so the trial will begin July 7, and will focus on two issues:
*Did Shelly Sterling properly comply with the terms of the Sterling Family Trust in having Donald removed as a co-trustee, or was Donald defrauded by Shelly and/or two doctors who examined him and found him to be mentally incapacitated?
*After Donald exercised his right to revoke the trust agreement on June 9, did Shelly have the legal right to go ahead with the sale of the Clippers to billionaire former Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer?
The first question will involve the details of how Sterling was examined and how the two doctors – Meril S. Platzer and James E. Spar – came to their conclusions, as well as an examination of the letters they wrote regarding Sterling's condition and whether those letters conform to the terms of the trust.
The second question is likely a legal argument about how a revoked trust is handled in a complicated situation like this, involving a $2 billion sales contract.
Shelly's lawyers claimed victory.
"We're very pleased the judge has agreed with us that this trial should have a very limited focus," attorney Pierce O'Donnell said.
Lawyer Adam Streisand, representing Ballmer, said, "They always wanted to make this about Donald's capacity. They backed off."
Bobby Samini, one of Donald Sterling's attorneys, said, without getting into specifics, that he will show that the medical examinations of Donald arranged by Shelly were "not complete, that there was fraud and that the letters (the doctors' findings) do not conform to the terms of the trust."
Donald was found to be mentally competent in a medical evaluation over the weekend, Sterling's lawyer, Maxwell Blecher, told USA TODAY Sports.
"As you might have expected, he has a contrary view," Blecher said.
Sterling was examined by Dr. Jeffrey Cummings, who has been identified by lawyers as a potential witness in the trial.
Blecher said he was told by his legal team that the evaluation showed that Sterling showed no lack of mental capacity but did show signs of mild cognitive impairment – a common condition considering his age, he said.
But Donald's lawyers ultimately abandoned the idea of asking the court to make a ruling on Donald's competency and focused instead on poking holes in Shelly's doctors' examinations.
Earlier Monday, Sterling's lawyers filed papers with the court alleging that Shelly had "duped" and "blindsided" her husband in the process of having two doctors certify in writing that he is mentally incapacitated.
Shelly, in complying with the terms of the trust, used those medical opinions to remove Donald as a co-trustee, then agreed to sell the Clippers to Ballmer.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nba/clippers/2014/06/30/donald-sterling-mentally-fit-clippers-new-doctor/11780415/