@Finn dAbuzz,
Finn dAbuzz wrote:
You don't seem to be able to grasp that I am not arguing for anyone. I'm arguing against rushing to judgment based on ideological assumptions, and sketchy and contradicting reports.
If you are, that's great, and I tend to agree but you seemed to be making a general argument about how much license we give people to act against perceived threats that actually echoes the argument against SYG and, implicitly, Zimmerman, but you were making them against Trayvon's alleged actions.
Quote:If I have made an argument for how Martin's claims could be true it is to demonstrate that the folks who are so sure that they know what happened that night, don't really.
Good to know.
Quote:It is not difficult to imagine a scenario wherein Zimmerman shot the kid in actual self-defense, and it's not hard to imagine one wherein he did it because he wanted to take care of one of the punks he was sick and tired of. The former is justifiable; the latter not.
Unfortunately, I don't believe those are the only two possible scenarios, opening up all kinds of confusing legal and moral questions. This is why I focus on who had the most responsibility for the situation. Admittedly, this is only my judgment and my opinion about how it
should be.
Quote:I'm also arguing against the hypocrisy of those who find this case one of clear cut injustice, but not the one in Arizona.
You don't think that's largely due to lack of information?
Quote:These are the folks who claim that the only racial element they're focused on is that if had been Martin and not Zimmerman who shot someone in alleged defense, he would have been arrested and thrown in jail.
Frankly, the Arizona case has not changed my opinion on this. Possibly because Trayvon was a kid, maybe because I know Florida, maybe because in this case Zimmerman had already primed the police to believe Trayvon was a criminal.
Quote:This case has been so racially charged by people who benefit by racial tension that I'm afraid that it doesn't matter how it is resolved. The folks who have been filled with anger over this case are not going to let it easily go, no matter what.
I see this as a diversion which is why I don't really engage in this aspect of the case. But I think it's been racially charged in both directions -- with white supremacists posting pictures of some other gang banger kid and claiming it's Trayvon, and just generally smearing the kid. There are racial aspects to this case that should be discussed, but the thing to do about the circus is to pretend it doesn't exist, not use it to invalidate the fundamental claim for justice that is behind this story.