@hamilton,
Well I say that you're wrong for the explaination that you called your question a "simple question". The only way in which you could really say Nay nay would be if you complicated the question in which was not in the criteria of the original question. So the only way in which you could say nay nay would be to change the question. I'm really just nit-picking with that so I'll just assume that you wish to change the question.
It really depends what the nature of your question branches from, since you've stated this in philosophy, you are wrong. A pot-shot would be that it exist due to the fact that you have addressed it and typed it out. So at least as a word and idea, it exist philosophically and that's really all that's needed to make the point valid.