@Professor Chaos,
Quote:Why should they just stop their extreme actions if they truly believe it is God's way? Would you stop believing just because people didn't like what you were doing? Would you defy God if he told you to kill?
They should stop their extreme actions, because they have a consience which oposes that idea, if not then they will eventually commit a terrorist act. I wouldn't defy him, I would gently ask him to explain himself, you see first he tells us not to kill, then he tell us the oposite? I doubt God would ask any of us to do that anyways, if he wants someone dead what's stoping him? Unless it is not God asking...
Quote:In regards to the rule of God, I would imagine the penalties for just changing them when you want to be quite severe. Faith in God aside, you then need faith in whoever translated the Good Book for you! Talk about a long shot of actually getting it right.
Personally I stick to the New Testament, one reason is that many times during his teaching Jesus said : Hear those who have ears to listen. That identifies an implied meaning to what he had previously said, that requires interpretation to find, IMO you should do that yourself, not rely on anyone else to interprate for you.
Also these rules that were set up, be them in any secular religion, are directly related to the needs of the people at the time, being so we also must relate them to our needs in our time.
Quote:Seeing as eternal damnation may be at stake shouldn't there be a more concrete set of rules? How do you know you're living to the correct interpretation? You might be just as damned as the heathens.
To me eternal damnation is a mechanizim to control the actions of people, it is one aspect of the bible that was never interpreted in a diferent context by the Christian Church, at least not to my knowledge. What you "suffer" for your sins is the eternal guilt of having made them, but by repenting and learning from your mistakes you can be sure not to make them again.
Quote:No, they're assuming their interpretation is correct. As you assume your version is, as Jews assume their version is etc, etc...........
I choose to believe, do they?
Quote:No, I mean what are the specific rules for living your life as a Christian? Muslims have a cast iron set of rules, the literal word of God, to base their lifestyles on. Christians just pick whichever parts of the Bible they see fit and forget the rest. How do you know God isn't pissed off about that?
He gave us free-will, I am sure he forsaw the consequences, but no doubt the benefits outweight it considerably.