Quote:as an after thought, I fear that someone will point out that the Alcibiades metaphor could better apply to Bush, given the war adventures in Sicily & Iraq. Point noted, however a consideration of the deeper aspects of character makes Kerry the unambguous choice.)
My god, george, this is not a paragraph you want to put on a placard and thrust high for all to see.
First of all, we note that indeed, after-thoughts are a grand thing with much to be said for them. In the same breath, we add there's also much to be said in commendation of those whose character allows even the odd after-thought to attend. But when your shiny DeSoto is already over the cliff-edge and descending rapidly towards the rocks far below, after-thoughts pale somewhat in appeal and, as your mother-in-law screeching in the backseat indicates, a little pre-thought can prove preferable (see the analogy above, or, see Iraq). "After-thoughts" and "George Bush" do not sit comfortably in the same paragraph. Hell, they don't sit comfortably in the same universe. Mistake one.
And then, of all historical figures you might invite in to stand beside Bush and Kerry, hoping to shine a favorable light on your fella, you choose Alcibiades?! Well, ok, this was your idea. Let's elucidate that which we know of Alcibiades and see where we find matches or mis-matches with your candidate...
- brilliant intellect and chummed around with possibly the greatest philosopher of the ancient world. Not really Dubya, is it?
- fought bravely in war. No, that doesn't fit either.
- born high and wealthy. Yup.
- blessed with the advantages of being raised in THE household where the powerful of the world traipsed in and out. Yup.
- notoriously insolent and petulant, which, because of his social position and wealth, few dared punish. Yup, good fit on that one.
- little if any genuine belief in democratic institutions (Thucydides has him speaking of democracy as 'acknowledged folly'). Well, here we have the most profound similarity between Bush and Alcibiades, along with this last descriptor following,
- saw his way to power through war and conquest.