@Adam101,
Adam101;95455 wrote: All of our actions are based off of thoughts and feelings. I doubt one could ever completely suppress either, though it's fun to practice in meditation.
I agree. The two seem to be linked, though I can say that under certain circumstances I certainly do less of one compared to another. My best tennis, no doubt, is when I am just dropping thought and feeling the racquet, the ball, and imagining the flight/trajectory of the ball.
My guess is that poker is full of all kinds of approaches. The best, I have found, are those who don't care if they go broke. Wild abandon. But they do all go broke at one time or another.
Rich
---------- Post added 10-06-2009 at 03:43 PM ----------
Didymos Thomas;95456 wrote:Mostly, muscle memory. Instead of thinking about which pattern to play, the patterns are natural due to muscle memory so I am able to reproduce them without much thought - they just come because they fit the music. Muscle memory is the key.
I am not sure what this thing called "muscle memory" is all about. Not that I do not believe there is such a thing, but memory supposedly is in the brain - something that I would debate.
In any case, mechanistic viewpoints about how memory develops cannot explain the ease that a young child prodigy, who has little training, can play an instrument or sing - or perform any of the arts or sports activities.
So, I would agree it is memory. But it seems like we are talking about a completely different memory than one we normally refer to.
Rich
---------- Post added 10-06-2009 at 03:45 PM ----------
Aedes;95468 wrote:My son does a LOT of thinking when he walks around, because he just learned how to do it. He watches his feet, he's cautious, he thinks about new things to try. You're not going to get innately good at any skill without concentrating on it first.
There are definitely many, many exceptions to this thought. I can think of so many when I think of young child prodigies - or even older people who suddenly discover a talent. Many artists I know fit this description.
Rich
---------- Post added 10-06-2009 at 03:48 PM ----------
Zetherin;95472 wrote:This thread is convinced that when one is feeling during an activity, one isn't thinking?
Qualitatively, there are totally different things going on within oneself when they are performing an activity using feeling (e.g. dancing) and thinking. It is not only observable by the person performing the activity, but is easily observable by someone who is watching. I remember watching the Olympics and the robot trained athletes appear to perform so differently from those who are doing it with feeling. There are definitely differences. Anyone who plays a musical instrument knows what I am talking about.
Rich
---------- Post added 10-06-2009 at 03:51 PM ----------
Didymos Thomas;95474 wrote:This is a definitional problem.
Not sure whether it is a definitional problem. I believe that there are clearly very different things going on within the being. You used the term "muscle memory". I think this is a good place to begin to better describe the qualitative differences. The feelings are different - but one first has to experience it to understand it. It is
being in the zone.
Rich