@NeitherExtreme,
Hello everybody,
I have tried to read most of the 47 comments on this subject and found very good points, in case you haven't read my comment on this subject in similar debates on
Philosophy/Metaphysic/Miracles and
Philosophy/Philosophy of religion/Miracles pages I reprint it here for the benefit of other readers [with minor alterations to suit this debate]:
Let us call "
Miracle" = a very rare event in a particular time and place and with intelligence or intend. [with "
will" or
ON DEMAND]
Some events are unheard of and called "
very rare events" [it is true]
A very rare event may be just
a "very rare event" [
if it happens by accident]
A very rare event may be called
a "miracle" [
if it happens on demand]
Let us say
X[/COLOR][/COLOR] = A man walked through the wall = a very rare event in particular time and location [let us assume]
Let us say
Y[/COLOR][/COLOR] = Red Sea crossing = a very rare event in particular time and location [let us assume]
Xa =
Miracle[/COLOR][/COLOR] [if
there is a will[/COLOR][/COLOR]]
Xb =
Not Miracle [if
there is not a known will]
Ya =
Miracle[/COLOR][/COLOR] [if
there is a will[/COLOR][/COLOR]]
Yb =
Not Miracle [if
there is not a known will]
In order to talk about miracles, which -by definition- requires intelligence/intend or "
will", we need to
prove that this "will[/COLOR][/SIZE][/COLOR][/SIZE][/COLOR][/SIZE]" is the cause of that particular event.
Now, the onus on the claimer's shoulder
to prove without doubt that, there is a miracle and in this particular miracle -the very rare event- happened
because of the "will" of the instigator.
Until now,
no reliable evidence have been provided to justify the claim [/U]that a "miracle" has actually happened.
However, people who has mistaken "
belief[/COLOR][/COLOR]" in particular dogma may take it as "
evidence" that a "
miracle[/COLOR][/COLOR]" happened
because a priest told them, or they have read it in a book or they have heard several eye witnesses account etc. Modern logic do not accept these evidences as final arbitrator.
There are
many opinions - but
the truth is one - and the job of philosophy is to find out the truth.