@Always Eleven to him,
David wrote:2. I see no "right" in the residents of Washington DC to be represented in Congress.
No one has to live there if he does not want to; its not a prison; no walls around it.
Always Eleven to him wrote:I think you've missed the point.
The citizens of the District of Columbia are first and foremost citizens of the United States.
Every other United States citizen is represented in Congress.
If you recognize a citizen's right to own firearms,
why do you not recognize the right of a citizen to be represented
by a full voting member of Congress?
Its a matter of simple definition rendered by the US Constitution, which is the Supreme Law of the Land.
The Constitutional set-up does
not provide for representation
in Congress from
other than States of America.
If u believe that it
DOES, then please quote the operative language,
or at least cite to the Article and Section wherein this theory is supported.
In my opinion, an amendment of the Constitution woud probably be necessary to accomplish this result.
Admittedly, I have not scrutinized the Constitution concerning this point because I don't care much about it.
I might be in factual error.
As to my recognition of a citizen's right to own firearms,
it
IS clearly set forth in the 2nd Amendment that government has no jurisdiction with respect
to any citizen 's right to bear arms. Remember: when the Bill of Rights was ratified in 1791,
there were
NO police anywhere in the USA,
nor were there any in England until the next century.
Every citizen was expected to defend his own life and property
from the predatory violence of man or beast; it was assumed that he 'd have the
means to do it.
In summary:
no vote for D.C. residents because that was
not how Congress was set up,
and
full freedom to keep and bear arms because the Constitution said so. (2nd Amendment; also the 9th Amendment)
It is only a question of reading the Constitution like a roadmap
and applying it
strictly and
mechanically.
U don 't argue with a roadmap; u read it and
u follow it.
David