@OmSigDAVID,
Quote:Not even a biological son is tolerable
when he turns his attentions and intentions to malice against his benefactor
You are quite right, threatening or menacing behavior should not be tolerated.
It should be properly evaluated and treated.
What this woman did is inexcusable. You don't put a young child on a plane by himself and send him back to another country--
for any reason.
The biological mother may have been an alcoholic, so this child may suffer from some degree of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome, or other neurological impairment, which may predispose him to behavioral problems, particularly problems with impulse control. Severe impulse control problems can be associated with explosive aggressive outbursts and behaviors like fire setting. These behaviors can be very difficult for a parent to manage--that is why they require professional intervention. Professional intervention would address treatment of the child's behavior as well as advising the parent on how to manage it.
When you adopt a child, you are the one who becomes responsible for the child. If the child displays psychiatric problems or behavioral problems, you are the one responsible for seeking evaluation and treatment for the child.
Do we know whether this woman ever got evaluation or treatment for this child?
This woman had the option of voluntarily placing the child in foster care, in this country. By moving to do so, she would have involved Family Court in the situation. That would have resulted in evaluation of the child, proper diagnosis of the problem, and a treatment plan. The Court could then have the child placed in an appropriate foster care setting or treatment facility if the child placed a risk to others, or have him simply removed from the home if the adoptive mother's behavior toward him was abusive, or if she simply couldn't manage him.
A larger issue in all of this is whether the Russian agency sufficiently informed this woman of the child's background and any existing behavior problems prior to the adoption. A prospective adoptive parent should know these things. I am reminded of the past flurry of adoptions from Romania when many adoptive parents found themselves with children with rather severe problems due to the past conditions of these children's lives.
Another issue is the fact that this sort of adoption, of an older child from a foreign country, can be extremely stressful for the child, particularly for a child who may not have adequate coping mechanisms to begin with. The child is removed from a world that is familiar to him--including his language, the foods he eats, his familiar caretakers, whatever attachments he has formed--and is placed in a strange new environment. This alone can trigger serious behavior problems in the child, and if the adoptive parent doesn't understand this, or fails to get appropriate professional help, or responds inappropriately, these problems intensify and escalate.
No matter what the situation was in this case, what the adoptive mother did, by putting that child on the plane, was wrong. She violated her state laws regarding child abandonment. She should be punished for that. She had other options and she should have used them.