@ehBeth,
My daughter and I email some of those best and worst choices in clothes back and forth to each other. We often wonder what is so bad about the worst and what is so good about the best. Why is something that is ugly considered fresh?
What amazes me is how there seems to be a theme (for want of a better word) every year. This year, it is swirls and ruffles. A few years ago, all of the dresses were one shoulder affairs while the year Julia Roberts won best actress, the dresses were simple and stately.
Is there only one designer who produces all of those clothes under different names or do the designers get together to decide what element each dress should have so that the dresses look alike?
Don't blush over enjoying catty comments either. It is vicarious fun.