mckenzie wrote:Quote:Lastly, godawful cheap flooring (see above photo) that is seriously glued to the floor so even if I pull it up the floor underneath is damaged.
We are in the process of replacing the carpeting and kitchen/bathroom flooring in one of our rental properties and are facing a similar problem to yours, Boomerang, in the kitchen. We chose what we thought was a good combination of carpeting and vinyl flooring. When the installer from Home Depot came out to give us an estimate for the installation, he said that trying to take up the glued on flooring underneath wasn't a good idea. He recommended
Trafficmaster Allure to be installed overtop of the existing flooring.
The reviews that I've read on Home Depot's website appear to be positve, overall.
I just did 2 kitchens and 4 bathrooms back in June with that TrafficMaster Allure product (in the "Corfu" color) and it is a nice product - both to work with and the final finish. I've come to really like the product.
For one thing, it is thicker than any self-stick tile I've ever seen (twice as thick as most of them!) so it has less chance of tearing/being cut through. It also allows it to be installed on less-than-prefect subfloors or over existing flooring without telegraphing imperfections.
It also doesn't actually stick to the old floor at all. It has tabs on the edges much like laminate flooring does. The pieces stick to each other so you end up with a once piece floating floor. When you lay in the sections you can heat the seam with a heat gun or hair drier and soften up the glue so that you can push the sections together tightly and the seams disappear completely. Because of the tabs you also end up with a water tight floor, something you don't get with self-stick tiles. Any DIYer could install this stuff with ease. The last bathroom I did was about 3 hours to remove the toilet, sink/vanity and baseboards, install flooring and resinstall everything.
My only complaint about this stuff thusfar is that color choices are pretty limited. I wish they'd come out with more patterns.