Bottom line... If you want a small 4x4 that is dead nuts reliable, get a Toyota. The other Japanese offereings like the Nissan, Mitsubishi, and Mazda are all fine alternatives, the the hands down winner is Toyota.
The American offerings are fine. They don't offer the reliability, but at least parts are cheap in the states and you can usually fix them in 20 minutes with common hand tools
I had a 95 S10 with 140k miles that sold for $200 with a sick engine. I had an 86 Toyota with 220k that sold for $1500 with lots of life left in it. Resale value should be part of your decision.