What Paul Cellucci said makes sense. Acknowledging that the Northwest Passage is Canadian territory allows more control for the Canadian Navy and thus improves security.
It is also true that this is mostly about petroleum reserves (as georgeob said).
Canada's navy does not have the physical ability to control or even patrol the Northwest passage - much less to even monitor Russian submarine operations there. They complain to us because we are relatively open about it , but never to the Russians or the former Soviet state.
Oil Barrels in the Arctic (AP photograph)
give it to the ruskees they deserve it......................
The NYT essay is a bit misleading. Currently recognized international law already recognizes the economic exclusion zones that affect the United States. We have very little to gain by this treaty and much to lose.
From Walter's Link:
Quote:Because of the great potential of the Arctic, the USGS has undertaken a comprehensive assessment of the area in order to provide consistent and comparable geologically based estimates of the potential additions to world oil and gas reserves. Northeastern Greenland is the prototype for the USGS Circum-Arctic Resource Appraisal, and the USGS will be releasing assessments of all the Arctic provinces over the next year.
The USGS estimates the mean undiscovered, conventional petroleum resources in the province to be approximately 31.4 billion barrels of oil equivalent of oil, gas, and natural gas liquids. In comparison to the world´s 500 other oil and gas provinces, if this resource is proved and realized, northeastern Greenland would rank 19th.
(Wandel Sea is located at the northeastern coast of Greenland.)
did you notice "valdemar gluckstadt land" ?
i wonder if JW has staked his claim yet ? :wink:
hbg
Walter and Hbg,
As you know, Denmark and the United States have sent teams of scientists to that area. (I have sent a team of attorneys.)
jw :
i'm overjoyed that you are giving the attorneys some of your valuable businesss
LOTS A RUCK ! :wink:
hbg
VIKINGS NOT WELCOME !
(from toronto's "globe and mail)
we'll show those scruffy vikings who's the boss around here
Quote:NORTHWEST PASSAGE
Viking invaders turned back from our shores
Canada's border agency orders two members of Nordic adventure crew to be deported after misleading RCMP
BILL CURRY
September 1, 2007
Fuelled by a desire for adventure and a significant amount of alcohol, a group of young men calling themselves the Norwegian Wild Vikings have sailed through the icy waters of the Arctic and Antarctic.
They have come face to face with polar bears and have annoyed giant walruses - poking them with their horned Viking hats.
They have navigated their small sailboat - which is painted to look like a shark and is called the Berserk II - through dangerous, iceberg-filled waters.
But the Norwegian Wild Vikings were no match for the Canada Border Services Agency.
According to a report from CBC News, two members of the Wild Vikings were ordered deported Thursday after their captain admitted that he hid a crew member from the RCMP while in Nunavut.
The deportation decision was reportedly made at a hearing Thursday in Cambridge Bay.
The two men ordered deported were identified as Captain Jarle Andhoy and Jeffrey Kane.
Mr. Andhoy raised the sensitive issue of Arctic sovereignty in explaining why he did not feel it was necessary to let Canadian officials know of their plans to sail the Northwest Passage.
"We are not here to visit Canada. We are here to do a transit to the Pacific," Mr. Andhoy was quoted as telling CBC News. "We're sailing the Northwest Passage and as far as I'm concerned the Northwest Passage is international."
Canada maintains that all waters in between the Arctic islands are part of Canada. However, most other countries argue that everything beyond 12 nautical miles from the island shores is international waters.
According to the CBC report, a crew member of the Wild Vikings had previously been ordered deported when the crew stopped in Halifax earlier this year. Canada had deported the man, and arrested another, claiming they were associates of the Hell's Angels. The Vikings' own website appears to confirm that association.
Mr. Andhoy admitted to CBC that he later picked up the deported crewmate in Greenland and dropped him off on land in Nunavut before docking at Gjoa Haven and Cambridge Bay. The report said criminal charges were pending.
Through the group's website and its videos posted on YouTube, the young Vikings broadcast their tales of adventure and misadventure.
Though their videos have beautiful shots of polar wildlife, it's a far cry from the Discovery Channel. They film themselves drinking on board with the Russian Coast Guard. They also film the aftereffects of drinking in less exotic urban locales. Drunken arguments in a cab over whether to hit the Pita Pit or to pick up a slice of pizza were deemed worthy of filming and sharing by the Vikings.
Through a "captain's log," the Vikings blog about their current trip, which started in Cuba and passed by the Statue of Liberty in New York.
"But here - upon entering Canada - everything went horribly wrong," the blog reads. "First, 13 heavily armed police officers and customs agents boarded the Berserk with a mission. Immediately they arrested Super, the expedition's mechanic, and tossed him in jail due to his membership in Norway's Hell's Angels ... Two days after Super was arrested, the police returned - but not with answers. This time they arrested Fred the cook."
WILD VIKINGS' MISSION STATEMENT
"The crew onboard Berserk II wish to pick up the old Norsemen traditions as opposed to today's so-called "civilized" and often artificial way of living. Instead of being a part of the PlayStation generation, in a 7-4 life with computers, electrical tin openers and washing machines, they seek adventures and exploration in the spirit of the ancient Vikings. Simply equipped on a low budget, the Wild Vikings turn the time back to the old days when men were men. Back to basics. Back to nature in harmony with its simple and real beauty to the world's remote corners."
Source: Wild Vikings website